Social
Competencies
Adolescent Violence
Bibliography
Theories: Culture of Violence Theory:
Felson, R. B., Liska,
A. E., South, S. J., & McNulty, T. L. (1 994). The subculture of violence
and delinquency: Individual vs. school context affects. Social Forces,
73(1), 155-173.
Wolfgang, M., &
Ferracuti, F. (1967). The subculture of violence. London: Travistock.
Wolfgang, M., &
Ferracuti, F. (1982). The subculture of violence (2nd edition). London:
Travistock.
|
The culture of violence theory is a socio-cultural
theory that explores the influence of the larger culture upon the individuals
within it. The key component theories of violence (e.g., availability of
guns, gang membership, incidences of mob violence, glamorized violence)
attempt to explain the etiology of aggressive behavior but each have failed
to provide a comprehensive explanat ion for violence. Recently a shift
has occurred in the social sciences whereby greater emphasis is being placed
on interrelatedness of the individual, interpersonal, and macrosocial variables. |
Instinct Theory:
Freud, S. (1950).
Beyond the pleasure principle. New York: Liveright.
Lorenz, K. (1966).
On aggression. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World.
McDougall, W. (1908).
Introduction to Social Psychology. London: Methuen.
Trotter, W. (1916).
Instincts of the herd in peace and war. New York: Macmillan.
|
Instinct theories assert that aggressive behavior
is rooted in biological or instinctual influences. Proponents of instinct
theory argue that humans are prewired for an instinctive aggressive energy
that requires no prior learning. Rather, its release is contingent upon
provocation by specific environmental and interpersonal social stimuli.
The implication is that violence prevention efforts are futile since aggression
is caused by unchangeable biological or instinctual factors. Although instinct
theories are useful for understanding the neurophysiological processes
involved in aggression, they ignore the impact of learned cognitive and
social factors. |
Drive Theory:
Dollard, J., Doob,
L. W., Miller, N. E., Mowrer, O. H., & Sears, R. R. (1939). Frustration
and aggression. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Berkowitz, L. (1982).
Aversive conditions as stimuli to aggression. In L. Berkowitz (Ed.), Advances
in experimental social psychology (Vol. 15, pp. 3-15). San Diego, CA: Academic
Press.
Berkowitz, L. (1989).
The frustration-aggression hypothesis: An examination and reformulation.
Psychological Bullentin, 106, 59-73.
|
Drive theory suggests that aggressive behaviors
are motivated by internal drives initiated by external stimuli. The most
prominent drive theory is the frustration-aggression theory developed in
1939 by Dollard, Doob, Miller, Mowrer, & Sears. They argue that the
occurrence of aggressive behavior always presupposes the existence of frustration
and contrariwise, the existence of frustration always leads to some form
of aggression. Although frustration is viewed by most social scientists
as a likely cause of aggression, it is believed that to a greater extent,
responses are determined by learned social and cognitive factors. |
Conflict Theory:
Dahrendorf, R (1968).
Essays in the theory of society. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
|
According to conflict theory, conflict is a
normal and inevitable part of human interactions and relationships. It
is not conflict per se that is problematic but rather the maladaptive ways
with which humans tend to respond to conflict. From this perspective then,
violence can be viewed as a maladaptive mode of resolving conflict when
other modes of resolution fail or break down. Break down may occur due
to faulty conflict management processes, lack of conflict resolution skills,
or lack of perceived options. |
Psychopathology
Theory:
Lewis, D. O., Shanock,
S. S., Pincus, J. H., & Glaser, G. H. (1979). Violent juvenile delinquents:
Psychiatric, neurological, psychological, and abuse factors. Journal of
the American Academy of Child Psychiatry, 2, 591-602.
|
Psychopathological theories contend that mental
abnormalities and disorders are the causal agents of violence. In contrast
to situational or stimulus provocation, research in this area suggests
that aggressive behavior are associated with neural and severe psychological
trauma. Psychopharmacological methods are often the intervention of choice. |
Social-learning
Theory:
Bandura, A., &
Walters, R. H. (1963). Social learning and personality development. New
York: Hold, Rinehart, & Winston.
Bandura, A., &
Walters, R. H. (1959). Adolescent aggression. New York: Ronald.
Parke, R. D., &
Slaby, R. G. (1983). The development of aggression. In P. H. Mussen (Series
Ed.), and E. M. Hetherington (Vol. Ed.), Hand book of child psychology
(Vol. 4, pp. 547-641). New York: Wiley.
|
Social-learning theory is based primarily on
the early work of Bandura and Walters (1959). The basic premise is that
aggressive behavior is acquired and maintained through observational learning,
direct experience, and self-regulative influences. Research in the area
of social-learning focuses on controllable environmental, cognitive, and
self-regulative factors that may lead to aggression. However, social learning
theory ignores the social context within which behavior is learned or performed. |
Social Cognition
Theory:
Social cognition theory is a set of principles that has yet to be integrated
into a single overarching theory. The focus of these theories is how cognitive
factors may help to account for the acquisition, maintenance, developmental
changes, and control or prevention of aggression and violence. Cognitive
factors are hypothesized to: be acquired through learning, contribute to
proactive exposures and interpretations of social experiences, mediate
aggressive responses to particular social experiences, account for individual
consistencies and continuities in patterns of aggression, victimization,
and bystander support for violence, and be amenable to change (Pepler &
Slaby, 1994). Thus, the theory argues that certain cognitive components,
such as attributions, attitudes, and beliefs, mediate the effects of strong
emotional arousal on the violent behavioral responses of the aggressor,
and because these cognitive components are learned, they are changeable.
Dodge, K. A. (1991).
The structure and function of reactive and proactive aggression. In D.
J. Pepler, & K. H. Rubin (Eds.), The development and treatment of childhood
aggression (pp. 201-218). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Pepler, D. J., &
Slaby, R. G. (1994). Theoretical and developmental perspectives on youth
and violence. In L. D. Eron, J. H. Gentry, & P. Schlegel (Eds.), Reason
to hope: A psychosocial perspective on violence and youth. Washington,
D. C.: American Psychological Association.
Other Theoretical Perspectives:
Impression Management:
Felson, R. B. (1982).
Impression management and the escalation of aggression and violence. Social
Psychology Quarterly, 45 (4), 245-254.
|
According to impression management, the basic
determinate of aggression is a perceived intentional attack. Among the
hypotheses tested by the author were: persons were more likely to verbally
attach an antagonist during a conflict if they were insulted; males were
more likely than females to attack an antagonist verbally when they have
been insulted; and conflicts were likely to be more severe when there were
third parties present. Findings generally support the hypotheses and the
impression management theory of aggression and violence. Although this
article is not specifically geared towards adolescents per se, the information
and findings could be extrapolated and assist towards an understanding
of adolescent aggression and violence. |
Felson, R. B. (1981).
An interactionist approach to aggression. In. J. T. Tedeschi (Ed.), Impression
management theory and social psychological research. New York: Academic
Press.
|
The authors look at aggression from the point
of view of symbolic interaction theory with an emphasis on impression management.
It is argued that some studies are available describing the situational
factors in homicide and assault and a few examine the interaction of the
participants and processual development of the incident. But that no one
has described quantitatively what actually occurs in aggressive interactions.
In order to study aggression quantitatively, a procedure is developed describing
the sequence of events that occur in aggressive encounters of varying severity.
Aggression is discussed as an interactive dynamics and processual development
of aggressive encounters, the legitimization of aggression, aggression
as punishment for deviance, the norm of reciprocity, and the "fair fight." |
Mason,
W. A. (1998). Impression management, violence, and self-esteem: A social
interactionist approach to coercive action among adolescent males. Dissertation:
University of Nevada, Reno.
|
In this study, coercion as a form of strategic
self-presentation among adolescent males was examined. Data from the first
two waves of the Youth in Transition study of 2,213 tenth-grade adolescent
males were reanalyzed using structural equation modeling procedures. Results
showed that external locus of control among the respondents had no influence
on subsequent aggression. In addition, contrary to expectations, involvement
in aggression led to more external locus of control and to decreased self-esteem.
Further analyses revealed that self-esteem had a significant negative effect
on aggression only for those with stable self-esteem. Overly positive self-appraisals
of intellectual ability were not associated with coercive action among
the young men. The results suggest that investigations of the link between
self-esteem and aggression should look beyond global levels of self-worth
to the influence of other factors such as self-esteem. The findings also
suggest that violence might be reduced by providing young men (and women)
with opportunities to develop a more stable sense of self-worth within
the context of supportive reference groups. |
Reviews of Juvenile
Violence Literature:
Englander, E., K.
(1997). Understanding violence. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
|
In presenting a summary of what we know about
the causes and effects of violence, this work draws on contemporary research
and theory in sociology, clinical psychology, psychiatry, social work,
neuropsychology, behavioral genetics, child development, and education.
Emphasized are the interactive role of nature and nurture in development.
The book is divided into two sections. The first section entitled general
issues discusses issues such as commonality of violence, the social causes
of violence, television and violence, and biosocial model of violence.
The second section entitled special issues addresses issues such as substance
abuse, gangs, sexual assault, spouse homicide, and child abuse and physical
punishment. An epilogue discusses preventing and controlling crime. An
extensive reference section is provided. |
Loeber, R., &
Stouthamer-Loeber, M. (1998). Development of Juvenile aggression and violence:
Some common misconceptions and controversies. American Psychologist, 53
(2), 242-259.
|
Addressed are five misconceptions and controversies
concerning the development of aggression and violence in adolescents. The
five misconceptions and controversies were selected because of their importance
to the field and because of their relevance for applications a nd the formulation
of theories. Each is discussed in the context of empirical findings. The
five categories are: 1) misconception that high stability coefficients
of aggression over time imply that discontinuity of aggression from childhood
to early adult hood are negligible; 2) misconception that all serious forms
of violence have an origin in aggression during early childhood; 3) the
assumption that the development of violence in women is very similar to
that in men; 4) the controversy about whether a single pathway or multiple
pathways best represent individuals' development of antisocial behavior,
including violence; and 5) the controversy about whether causes of violence
are similar to the causes of property offending. |
Prothrow-Stith,
D., & Weissman, M. (1991). Deadly consequences. New York: Harper-Collins.
|
A former U. S. Surgeon General who declared
that violence is a public health issue is the author of this book. Youth
violence is presented from a variety of perspectives, including teaching
our kids to kill, poverty, adolescence as a time of dangerous passage,
violence and young males, and especially young males of color, gangs, and
drugs and gangs. A public health approach is presented along with information
for helping prevent violence in families, schools, and communities. |
Pepler, D. J., &
Slaby, R. G. (1994). Theoretical and developmental perspectives on youth
and violence. In L. D. Eron, J. H. Gentry, & P. Schlegel (Eds.), Reason
to hope: A psychosocial perspective on violence and youth. Washington,
D. C.: American Psychological Association.
|
The initial portion of this chapter provides
an overview of the theoretical foundations regarding the etiology and development
of aggression and violence and includes brief summaries of the leading
theories of aggression and violence. The second portion of the chapter
focuses on gender differences in the development of aggression and violence.
Examined are biological factors, type of aggression, socialization experiences,
and developmental outcomes of aggression and violence. The chapter concludes
with suggestions for prevention, intervention, and social policy development
on adolescent violence and aggression. |
State Justice Institute
(1996). Juvenile violence: A guide to research. Reno, NV: National Council
of Juvenile and Family Court Judges.
|
This guide is based on a selective review of
the research literature on juvenile violence. The stated objective was
to identify reports and findings related to the needs of the courts to
understand juvenile violence and plan appropriate responses. Among the
topics presented are the general characteristics of the juvenile population,
statistics, types of violence, risk factors, gender issues, and violence
prevention and intervention. The prevention and intervention is broken
into appropriate age groups including prenatal/perinatal, birth to age
4, ages 4-6, ages 7-12, and adolescence (ages 13-18). |
Bullying, School-related
Violence and Victimization:
Felson, R. B., Liska,
A. E., South, S. J., & McNulty, T. L. (1994). The subculture of violence
and delinquency: Individual vs. school context affects. Social Forces,
73 (1), 155-173.
|
Data was obtained from the first two waves of
the Youth in Transition data set, a multi-wave panel study. This panel
study consisted of personal in terviews and questionnaires administered
to 2,213 high school boys. The first-wave consisted of data obtained from
interviews conducted with sophomores attending 87 randomly selected public
high schools. The second wave was conducted at the end of their junior
year (18 months later). The research indicates that individual values regarding
violence varies significantly among high schools such that in some high
schools an aggressive response to provocation is more likely to meet with
peer approval than in other schools. Violence was consistently found to
be related to the values in the school independent of the adolescent's
own individual-level values. This suggests a social control process and
contradicts the usual explanation of how the subculture of violence may
affect violent behavior. Subcultural differences in values were more likely
to be found for real groups that were small and which involved social interaction
between members. These findings suggest a limitation to the subculture
of violence thesis: the effects of subculture of violence appear to reflect
more general effects of a subculture of delinquency. Support was found
in that the values regarding violence generally predict other forms of
delinquency as well as they predict violence. It is argued that some groups
are more violent than others because they have a distinctive set of values
that either support or tolerate violence. |
Fried, S., &
Fried, P. (1996). Bullies & victims: Helping your child survive the
schoolyard battlefield. New York: M. Evans and Company, Inc.
|
Bullying is a complex factor involving culture,
community, school, family, and individual influences. These authors discuss
bullying with relation to physical abuse, verbal abuse, emotional abuse,
sexual abuse, and sibling abuse. Strategies are presented for empowering
children against bullies and for adult intervention. Specific preventive
strategies and programs are suggested and designed to engage the parents,
teachers, school administrators, students, and youth workers. They argue
that the first step is to build a national consensus that bullying is unacceptable
behavior and will not be tolerated anywhere that children congregate. |
Garofalo, J., Siegel,
L., & Laub, J. (1987). School-related victimizations among adolescents:
An analysis of National Crime Survey (NCS) narratives. Journal of Quantitative
Criminology, 3 (4), 321-338.
|
Narrative information from the National Crime
Survey (NCS) is used to explore school-related adolescent to adolescent
victimizations. Data analysis suggests that in large part, victimizations
result from peer interactions that occur in the course of routine daily
activities and then escalate to violence. Most offenses occurred among
adolescents that knew each other to some extent: well known (23%), casual
acquaintances (31%), or known by sight only (25%). Victimizations appeared
to be the result of bullying, injured pride resulting from perceived insults,
and misguided mischief rather than the result of calculated, predatory
attempts to injure. Discussed is the possibility of reducing or thwarting
victimization through the presence of a capable guardian (a capable adult)
and by supervision along the routes to and from school. |
Glover, D., &
Cartwright, N., with Gleeson, D. (1998). Towards bully-free schools: Interventions
in action. Buckingham: Open University Press.
|
In designing their intervention, the authors
recognize that families and the community are both involved in the development
of policies designed to make school life more enjoyable for students. The
curriculum provided can be integrated with school activities and subject
curriculum. The questions identify how schools can change attitudes leading
to a decline in all forms of bullying behavior, how action against bullying
leads to greater life quality in teaching and learning, and effects on
long-term school environment. Four positive trends were identified from
the research: increased awareness by schools for action against anti-social
behavior, a decrease in the incidence of serious and repeated acts of bullying,
evidence that most students want a better school environment and are willing
to work towards it, and recognition of individual rights to equality of
opportunity. |
Hoffman, A. M. (1996).
Schools, violence, and society. Westport, CT: Praeger Publishers.
|
This book presents a collection of authors and
their work relating to issues of violence in the school. Section one features
articles focusing on the problem of school violence, specifically with
relation to violence in the classroom, weapon carrying, and gangs. Section
two reviews the causes of school violence with a focus on the media and
television violence and the influence of child abuse and family violence.
The third section considers the issues of school security and related legal
issues. Sections four and five discuss specific programs and strategies
employed by schools around the United States for reducing school violence.
In the final section, Section five, a community-based approach is discussed.
Included for ease of reference are a selected bibliography, index, subject
index, and summary information on the contributors. |
Merton,
D. E. (1997). The meaning of meanness: popularity, competition, and conflict
among junior high school girls. Sociology of Education, 70, 175-191.
|
The author proposes that exploring meanness
is a starting point for understanding the connections between competition,
conflict, and popularity among high school females. It is argued that examining
these connections in the context of a "clique" allows a better understanding
of the socio-cultural construction of meanness in junior high school. |
Pellegrini, A. D.
(1998). Bullies and victims in school: A review and call for research.
Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 19 (2), 165-176.
|
It is argued by the author that much of school
violence is perpetrated by a specific group of youngsters, namely, bullies,
and their aggression is focused towards a very limited group of victims.
Bullies are defined as "youngsters who systematically and repeatedly target
another group against whom they aggress either directly or physically or
indirectly and relationally." Although there is considerable recent work
containing self-report and laboratory studies, Pellegrini argues it is
time to compliment this work with direct and indirect observational methods
in natural settings. The literature review cites extensively recent research
on bullies. Topic areas include a description of both the bully and the
victim, the establishment and maintenance of bully-victim relationships,
and both methodological and ethical issues. The author suggests two models
that may explain bully-victim relationships that may guide future research:
the instrumental use of aggression against weaker peers, and that aggressive
victims may use aggression reactively rather than proactively. |
Sudermann, M., Jaffe,
P. G., & Hastings, E. (1995). Violence prevention programs in secondary
(high) schools. In E. Peled, P. G. Jaffe, & J. L. Edleson (Eds.), Ending
the cycle of violence: Community responses to children of battered women.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
|
These authors describe the aspects of violence
in relationships and their effects on students and on the larger community.
Divided into sections, the chapter reviews the scope of the problem, describes
groups that need to become involved if violence prevention in schools and
communities is to become a reality, suggestions for starting preventive
programs and for teacher and student programs, including awareness events
and curriculum integration, advice on handling disclosures of violence,
locating resources, and finally, how to evaluate and obtain feedback from
a violence prevention program. The authors argue that large-scale attitude
changes can be achieved regarding violence in relationships and that adolescents
can play a critical role in shaping a violence-free society and in offering
assistance to peers in violent relationships. |
Adolescent Sex Offenders, Sexual Violence & Dating Violence:
Bergman, L. (1992).
Dating violence among high school students. Social Work, 37 (1), 21-27.
|
Students (n = 631) from three Midwestern suburban,
rural, and inner-city schools were assessed regarding their experiences
with sexual, physical, and verbal dating violence. The schools differed
significantl in racial composition, average family income, and occupational
trend. Findings indicate that the average proportion of students in the
sample reporting sexual dating violence was 10.5%. The majority told no
one about the violence, and those who reported physical violence also reported
continuing to date the perpetrators of the violence. Of those who reported
physical or sexual violence, 40.9% of the males and 45.1% of the females
reported repeat physical violence. The incidences of severe violence were
found to be related to number of dating partners, poor academic performance,
and frequency of dating. The highest incidence of dating violence was found
in the suburban schools, followed by inner-city schools, and rural schools,
respectively. The implications for practice are considered. |
Cowan, G., &
Campbell, R. R. (1995). Rape causal attitudes among adolescents. The Journal
of Sex Research, 32 (2), 145-153.
|
High school students from California (N = 453)
were compared on five possible causes of rape: male dominance, female precipitation,
society, male sexuality, and male pathology. Results indicate that gender,
ethnicity, age, and communication sources about rape, including pornography,
were related to attitudes about the causes of rape. Overall, adolescents
more strongly believed that rape is caused by individual perpetrator and
victim characteristics than by structural factors related to societal forces
and the ideology of male dominance. Each gender located the primary cause
of rape in the individual characteristics of the other gender. Females
rated male pathology as the most likely cause of rape, while males believed
more strongly in female precipitation and less strongly in male pathology
and male dominance than did females. Implications for rape educators are
discussed. |
Davis, G. E., &
Leitenberg, H. (1987). Adolescent sex offenders. Psychological Bulletin,
101 (3), 417-427.
|
This article reviews the literature on sexual
offences committed by adolescents. Reviewed are offense and victim characteristics,
offender characte ristics, and recidivism and treatment. Among the consistent
findings: 1) adolescents account for a large share of the sexual offenses
committed in this country, 2) two-thirds of the offenses are against younger
children and are committed by acquaintances or relatives of the victim,
3) there are generally more female than male victims, 4) almost all adolescent
sex offenders are male, 5) sex offenders frequently have a history of physical
abuse, behavioral and school disturbances are common but no more common
than among the history of delinquents who do not commit sexual offenses,
and 6) adolescent sex offenders claim to have more sexual experiences,
including consenting ones, than do comparison groups. The authors suggest
that one way in which future research can increase our understanding of
adolescent sexual offenders is by giving greater attention to studies that
involve matched comparison groups. |
Johnson, J. D.,
Adams, M. S., Ashburn, L., & Reed, W. (1995). Differential gender effects
of exposure to rap music on African American adolescents\rquote acceptance
of teen dating violence. Sex Roles, 33 (7/8), 597-605.
|
The effects of exposure to nonviolent rap music
on African American adolescents' perceptions of teen dating violence were
assessed using data from 30 males and 30 females, ages 11-16, from inner
city, low income families. Subjects were exposed to nonviolent rap videos
(which contained images of women in sexually subordinate roles) or they
saw no videos. All subjects read a vignette involving teen dating violence
perpetrated by a male. Findings indicate that the effects of exposure to
the rap videos were moderated by gender. Specifically, females exposed
to the videos reported greater acceptance of teen dating violence than
females who were not exposed to the videos. Male acceptance of teen dating
violence did not vary as a function of exposure to the videos. Implications
are discussed in terms of schematic constructs and prior attitudes. |
O'Keefe, M. (1997).
Predictors of dating violence among high school students. Journal of Interpersonal
Violence, 12 (4), 546-568.
|
Using a social-learning-theory-based model,
dating violence was examined in a racially/ethnically and socioeconomically
diverse sample of high school students. The sample consisted of 939 high
school students living in a large west coast metropolitan city. The racial
composition was 53% Latino, 20% White, and 13% African-American, 6.7% Asian
American, and 7% other. The Conflict Tactics Scales were used to assess
the amount of dating violence inflicted. Results indicated that violence
in dating was fairly frequent and that 43% of the females and 39% of the
males reported inflicting some form of physical aggression on their dating
partner at least once. Both males and females reported that males were
more frequently the initiators of dating violence. Both sexes reported
that to show anger was the most frequent for violent acts. Analysis of
variance indicated that African-American youths reported inflicting the
most dating violence. A multiple regression analysis for males however
indicated no significant racial/ethnic differences when the effects of
socio-demographic, contextual, and situational variables were controlled.
The limitations of the study are addressed in terms of self-report data,
convenience sample, and the violence reported neither the extent of injury
inflicted nor the context of the violent act. |
Worling, J. R. (1995).
Adolescent sex offenders against females: Differences based on the age
of their victims. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative
Criminology, 39 (3), 276-293.
|
The authors argue that arbitrarily combining
information from studies of adolescent rapists, child molesters, obscene
callers, exhibitionists, and voyeurs obscures potentially critical differences
between the subgroups. Data was obtained from 102 adolescent male sex offenders,
ages 12-19. Information regarding sexual offenses and victimization was
obtained from regular meetings (mean duration of meeting was 13 months)
as opposed to intake files or interviews. Data was also collected from
the following questionnaires: Youth Self-Report, Buss-Durkee Hostility
Inventory, Tennessee Self-concept Scale, Beck Depression Inventory, Rape-Myth
Acceptance Scale, Adversarial Sexual Attitude Scale, and the Assessing
Environments (III) Scale. Results indicate that those adolescents who sexually
assaulted female peers or adults were significantly more likely to have
received more physical parental discipline. Limitations are discussed in
terms of self-reports and that only those individuals who had sexual offended
were identified, resulting in a sample that may not be representative of
the population of sexual offending individuals. |
Gang Violence and Gang-related Issues:
Evans, W., Albers,
E., Macari, D., & Mason, A. (1996). Suicide ideation, attempts and
abuse among incarcerated gang and non-gang delinquents. Child and Adolescent
Social Work Journal, 13 (2), 115-126.
|
Self-reported data was collected from 334 males
and 61 females who were incarcerated in Nevada youth correctional facilities.
Over 58% of the males and 45% of the females reported gang membership.
Females, more than males, reported higher rates of physical and sexual
abuse, as well as suicide attempts. Non-gang members, more than gang members
reported more suicide attempts and reported more incidents of sexual abuse.
Limitations to the study are defined in terms of the small female sample
and vulnerability to over and under-reporting biases due to the use of
self-report measures. Future research suggestions include the need to study
youth from differing cultures and environments with regards to suicide
ideation and attempts in order to actually assess the risks associated
with varying levels of ideation and suicide attempts. In addition, prospective
longitudinal studies are needed to delineate the causal links among abuse,
gang involvement, delinquency, and suicidal behaviors. |
Goldstein, A. P.,
& Soriano, F. I. (1994). Juvenile gangs. In L. D. Eron, J.H. Gentry,
& P. Schlegel (Eds.), Reason to hope: A psychosocial perspective on
violence and youth. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
|
These authors provide a history, definitions,
and demographics telated to gang membership among adolescents. Explored
are the role of drugs, turf disputes, codes of honor, and the availability
of guns as related to increases in homicide and aggravated assaults among
gang members. Theory and programming interventions are discussed from several
disciplines namely: clinical, social, developmental, and community psychology.
They provide a culturally sensitive programming model which focuses upon
awareness, knowledge, and skills needed by program developers when developing
interventions programs among diverse ethnic groups. |
Howell,
J. C. (1997). Juvenile justice and youth violence. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
Publications.
|
This chapter is a summary of two reports prepared
by the author that review gang literature and youth gang violence prevention.
Reviewed in this article are research and data on the involvement of youth
gangs in drug trafficking and homicides, along with the history of youth
gang programming. Specific suggestions are made for reducing homicides
by youth gang members and for reducing gang participation. The "Comprehensive
Community-wide Approach to Gang Violence Prevention, Intervention, and
Suppression Program" is discussed in detail. This program emphasizes community
change as the main theoretical approach. A version of this program and
considered to be one of the most promising gang violence prevention and
intervention programs is the "Gang Violence Reduction Program" being conducted
in an area of Chicago. The program involves the use of suppression, social
intervention, opportunities provision, and community mobilization. |
Klein, M. W., Maxson,
C. L., & Miller, J. (1995). The modern gang reader. Los Angeles, CA:
Roxbury Publishing Company.
|
This work provides a comprehensive selection
of gang-related literature of what seems to be the most salient issues
surrounding current gang-related issues and controversies. Each article
includes a brief introduction and a list of additional readings that were
seriously considered for inclusion in this volume. Section one concerns
the nature of gangs and begins with definitions of gangs, examples of different
kinds of groups that can be classified as gangs and articles specifically
focused on females in gangs. Section two reviews the criminal involvement
of gang members focusing on what is known about gangs, including theories
and research methods. Section three focuses on the anti-social behavior
of gangs. Section four contains pertains to gang programs and policies.
Three articles are presented, each with a different emphasis: the attempt
to orient gang members in a more prosocial direction, the use of strong
law enforcement procedures to crack down on gangs and deter criminal behavior,
and examples of alternative social policies when dealing with gangs. |
Media Influence on Violence:
Anderson, C. A. (1997).
Effects of violent movies and trait hostility on hostile feelings and aggressive
thoughts. Aggressive Behavior, 23, 161-178.
|
These author argue that consensus is beginning
to emerge among researchers that observing violence in films can significantly
increase the violence of the observer. One way that violent media may increase
acts of violence is through its effects on affect and through cognitive
accessibility of aggressive thoughts. Results from a study investigating
the effects of affective and cognitive variables proposed to underlie movie
violence effects on aggressive behavior indicated that watching a brief
clip of moderately violent scenes produced an increase in feelings of hostility.
Further, watching the violent movie clip increased the relative accessibility
of aggressive thoughts and this accessibility to aggressive thoughts was
more prevalent in males than females. The audience had not been provoked
in any way. The authors discuss the possibility that hostile thoughts and
feelings may arise early in the aggressive behavior sequence. Too, the
relative accessibility of aggressive behavior programs and scripts could
influence aggressive thoughts, and affect may prime specific intentions
to act. Other speculations concern those individuals who start out with
higher levels of state hostility, the implications for their participants
not having been provoked, and effects of long-term exposure to violent
media depictions. |
Danish, S. J., &
Donohue, T. R. (1996). Understanding the media's influence on the development
of antisocial and prosocial behavior. In R. L. Hampton, P. Jenkins, &
T. P. Gullotta (Eds.), Preventing violence in America. Thousand Oaks, CA:
Sage Publications.
|
Rather than discussing only the negative influences
of the media, these authors discuss both the positive and the negative
influences. This stance is taken in a belief that the media provides major
educational tools that have been ove rshadowed by the negative influence
perspectives. The first part of their discussion focuses on the concept
of health-compromising and health-enhancing behaviors relating to life-span
development with special attention paid to the concept of life skills and
their relationship to healthy development. From here the articles moves
on to examine the historical relationship between societal violence and
the media and the research models and methods used to study this relationship,
as well as results of selected studies. The article then moves on to an
exploration of the impact of the media in teaching prosocial behavior and
life skills. Finally, the authors present a model is depicting the media
as a resource and explain how this resource can be used productively. According
to the authors, conclusions drawn from the effects of the media on youth,
regardless of the nature of the content, show that the media generally
reinforces preexisting attitudes, behaviors, and tastes; children learn
both positive and negative behaviors from the media and these learned behaviors
persist over time; there is an inverse relationship between the potential
effect of television and the impact of the family on children; for most
people, under most circumstances, the media has little impact as prosocial
and antisocial messages cancel each other out of the viewers repositories
of potential actions; most media effects are incidental and unintended
effects; and visual media is an unparalleled source for learning about
the world we live in. |
Derksen, D. J.,
& Strasburger, V. C. (1996). Media and television violence: Effects
on violence, aggression, and antisocial behaviors in children. In A. M.
Hoffman (Ed.), Schools, violence, and society. West Port, CT: Praeger Publishers.
|
These authors argue that television has a powerful
influence on the development of unhealthy activities, negative attitudes,
and antisocial behaviors of adolescents and that the effect is subtle and
ingrained over time by the repetition of images and stereotypes. Specifically,
these images and stereotypes promote distorted conceptions and information
about gender roles and violence as an acceptable solution to conflict resolution.
Media violence is discussed in terms of television, rock videos, video
games, and commercialism and their effects on school violence. They contend
that the major effects of violence, antisocial behavior, and aggression
in the media can be placed into six categories: displacement of healthy
activities, the modeling of inappropriate behavior, disinhibition, desensitization,
aggressive arousal, and association with risk-taking behavior. Factors
influencing violent and antisocial behaviors in schools include how aggression
is depicted (e.g., how directed toward women, justified retribution) and
rewarded aggression. Suggestions are made for limiting the effects of negative
television on youth. |
Donnerstein, E.,
Slaby, R. G., & Eron, L. D. (1994). The mass media and youth aggression.
In L. D. Eron, J.H. Gentry, & P. Schlegel (Eds.), Reason to hope: A
psychosocial perspective on violence and youth Washington, DC: American
Psychological Association.
|
The authors argue that violence in the mass
media is a significant contributor to aggressive behavior and aggression-related
attitudes among adolescents an d children. Overall, viewing violence in
the media can lead to youth increasing violence toward others. Additionally,
viewing violence in the media can lead to increases in the callousness
toward violence among others, increased fearfulness about becoming victims
of violence, and increased self-initiated behavior that exposes one to
further risk of violence. Discussed is a summary of research findings and
recent additional support for these findings, as well as theoretical models
offered by psychologists t o account for the relations between aggressive
behavior and exposure to mass media violence are reviewed. In conclusion
there are suggestions for interventions to reduce or prevent violence among
youth and policy recommendations. |
Friedlander, B.
Z. (1993). Community violence, children's development, and mass media:
In pursuit of new insights, new goals, and new strategies. Psychiatry,
56, 66-81.
|
The author argues that direct models of interpersonal
violence in families and in communities probably give rise to more violent
behavior than the indirect effects of the media. Using data from meta-analysis
which indicates that prosocial media messages have greater effects on behavior
than antisocial messages, it is argued that the media can play a strong
and positive role in alleviating some of the distress of victims of community
violence and redirecting behaviors of victimizers so as to protect children. |
Tedeschi, J. T.,
& Felson, R. B. (1994). Violence, aggression, and coercive actions.
Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
|
Authors reviewed the theoretical mechanisms
that researchers have associated with the effects of the media on violent
behaviors. These include imitation of media models, vicarious reinforcement,
cultural spillover, cognitive modeling, desensitization, creation of unrealistic
fear, and the routine activities approach to crime. Summaries of these
theories are followed by empirical evidence of media effects on aggression.
They conclude that exposure to media violence probably does have a small
effect on violent behavior. The authors base this tentative conclusion
on consistent results from laboratory experiments, supporting evidence
from field experiments, research on the effects of highly publicized violence
on homicide and suicide rates, the tendency for political and hijacking
violence to occur in waves, and anecdotal evidence that indicates that
bizarre events in the media are often followed by similar events in the
real world. If there is a media effect on violent behaviors, the mechanism
involved is unclear and leads the authors to believe that the message sent
by the media regarding the legitimacy of violence is ambiguous and likely
to have different effects on different viewers. |
Adolescent Homicide, Parracide and Parental-Focused Violence:
Busch, K. G., Zagar,
R., Hughes, J. R., Arbit, J., & Bussell, R. E. (1990). Adolescents
who kill. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 46 (4), 472-485.
|
Seventy-one adolescent delinquents, 4 females
and 67 males ages 10 to 17, who were convicted of homicide were matched
with 71 nonviolent adolescent delinquents by age, race, sex, and socioeconomic
status. Results indicate that adjudicated (judged in court) adolescents
who kill have a tetrad of symptoms that differentiate them from adjudicated
but nonviolent adolescents. Specifically, the symptoms were criminally
violent family members, gang membership, severe educational difficulties,
and alcohol abuse. The authors argue that adolescents who kill are not
exotic individuals but persons with violent, abusive, inconsistent, and
aggressive environments. |
Hardwick, P. J.,
& Rowton-Lee, M. A. (1996). Adolescent homicide: Towards assessment
of risk. Journal of Adolescence, 19, 263-276.
|
The author argues that in the training of child
and adolescent mental health professionals the assessment and management
of dangerousness to others is frequently overlooked. A review of the relevant
literature on homicidal youth is presented and background factors relevant
to risk are described. Background factors include witnessing serious violence
and abuse through neglect and deprivation. Those youth most at risk are
those with the greatest number and degree of severity of risk factors.
One problem discussed by the authors is the lack of effective intervention
programs when assessment indicates high risk of dangerousness. Directions
for future research are discussed. |
Myers, W. C., Scott,
K., Burgessd, A. W., & Burgess, A. G. (1995). Psychopathology, biopsychosocial
factors, crime characteristics, and classification of 25 homicidal youths.
Journal of American Academy of Child Adolescent Psychiatry, 34 (11), 1483-1489.
|
Using a combination of diagnostic interviews,
clinical interviews, record reviews, and other available relevant data,
25 homicidal children and adolescents, ages 7-17 were assessed. The sample
consisted of 28% white adolescents, 68% black, and 4% other. Only 12% of
the sample were female. It was found that histories of abuse, prior violence,
arrests, and promiscuous sexual behaviors were typical, as were family
and school dysfunction. Crime-based and conflict-based motives were evenly
divided. A weapon was used in 96% of the crimes. One finding of interest
indicated that those adolescents that committed a sexual homicide were
more likely to have engaged in overkill, used a knife, and been armed beforehand.
The authors suggest that research is needed in three areas: the area of
homicidal motivations by youths before specific interventions can be implemented,
longitudinal studies to test whether school and school-based family interventions
can reduce violent behavior, increase school performance, and decrease
family dysfunction, and the use of standardized terminology for communication
purposes in future studies of youth who murder. |
Poverty and Violence:
Greene, M. B. (1993).
Chronic exposure to violence and poverty: Interventions that work for youth.
Crime & Delinquency, 39 (1), 106-124.
|
Three assumptions form the basis for the article:
exposure to poverty and violence is traumatic, that specific deleterious
effects result from these traumas, and that specific programmatic interventions
must be adopted to counter these effects. Adolescents need assistance in
finding something to believe in, finding network support, and finding opportunities
that provide satisfying and productive forms of expression. It is argued
that for programs to work neighborhood youth centers must engage adolescents
in program planning and operation. It is argued that for programs to be
successful it is essential that they include the following nine elements:
street outreach and referral; needs and interest assessments; provisions
for supportive, personal relationships with adults; availability of role
models; peer groups discussions; family interventions; neighborhood projects;
education and job preparedness training; and program objectives. |
Gender Differences In the Development of Aggressive and Violent
Behaviors:
Pepler, D. J., &
Slaby, R. G. (1994). Theoretical and developmental perspectives on youth
and violence. In L. D. Eron, J.H. Gentry, & P. Schlegel (Eds.), Reason
to hope: A psychosocial perspective on violence and youth. Washington,
DC: American Psychological Association.
|
A brief overview of research on gender differences
is provided beginning with the fact that historically, research on gender
differences was limited to studies of males due to the assumption that
aggression was primarily a male domain. Thus, though information regarding
aggression in females is limited there is growing recognition that biology
is not t he primary determinate of gender differences in aggression. Rather,
biological influences are closely intertwined with social and psychological
factors. Gender differences are also attributed to socialization within
the family and among peers. However, women today are challenging the traditional,
stereotypic roles in society, roles that may be responsible for contributing
to gender differences in aggression. And over the past decade researchers
have noticed a decline in gender differences in aggression. One explanation
given for this decline is changing societal norms and roles for the genders.
Some discussion is given to developmental outcomes with regards to regression.
It is suggested that due to differences in the developmental trajectories
of males and females there is a need to search for the long-term sequelae
of aggressive behavior problems in different domains for males and females.
Thus it is critical to look at the influences of the social milieus of
adolescents at various stages of development before developing and implementing
violence prevention and intervention programs. |
Sibling Violence:
Felson,
R. B. (1983). Aggression and violence between siblings. Social Psychology
Quarterly, 46 (4), 271-285.
|
Two theoretical models for sibling violence and aggression are discussed.
The sibling rival model implies that conflicts occur more frequently when
siblings are of the same sex and when the younger sibling is more successful
or more favored by parents. Thus the model suggests that aggression between
siblings is a reflection of jealousy and nonrealistic conflict. The realistic
conflict model suggests that sibling conflicts arise over tangible goods
and the performance of devalued tasks due to unclear proprietary rights
and division of labor. If parental intervention is anticipated, overt conflict
is likely to occur because the younger sibling is then willing to fight
their more powerful older sibling. This model predicts that the greater
the age difference (and thus strength) between the siblings the more the
younger sibling will seek parental intervention. The more the parents intervene,
the more willing the younger sibling is to fight. If the age difference
between the siblings is large and the parents take on a Laissez-faire approach
or if they have invested greater authority in the older sibling then aggression
is less. In this study support was found for the realistic conflict model
but not for the sibling rivalry model. |
Worling,
J. R. (1995). Adolescent sibling-incest offenders: Differences in family
and individual functioning when compared to adolescent nonsibling sex offenders.
Child Abuse & Neglect, 19 (5), 633-643.
|
A study of 60 adolescent male sex offenders found that adolescent sibling-incest
offenders reported significantly more marital discord, parental rejection,
physical discipline, negative family atmosphere, and general dissatisfaction
with family relationships. Sibling-incest offenders were also more likely
to have been victims of childhood sexual abuse and to have younger siblings
in the family than were nonsibling offenders. The results indicate that
physical, emotional, and verbal family violence, together with a history
of sexual victimization and the availability of younger siblings, are associated
with the development of adolescent sibling-incest offenses. |
Substance Abuse and Adolescent Violence:
Kingery, P. M., Mirzaee,
E., Pruitt, B. E., Hurley, R. S., & Heuberger, G. (1991). Rural communities
near large metropolitan areas: Safe havens from adolescent violence and
drug use? Health Values, 15 (4), 39-48.
|
Most violent acts occurring within the educational environment are
adolescent-to-adolescent and drugs are often directly or indirectly involved
in these violent acts. This study consisted of 1004 8th and 10th grade
adolescent students in 23 small central Texas communities surrounding the
Houston metropolitan area and having an average daily attendance of fewer
than 5,000 students. Among the variables assessed were the prevalence of
violence among the students compared to national norms, their beliefs,
and behaviors regarding violence, and the connection between those factors
and drug use. Results indicated that more than half of the boys (53.2%)
and one-fifth of the girls (20.5%) reported engaging in at least one physical
fight during the previous year. One-fourth of the students had carried
a weapon at school. Most students believed that they should fight if someone
hits them (78.6%), hurts someone they care about (74.2%), insults someone
in their family (58.6%), or breaks something of their on purpose (53.1%).
Those engaging in drug use placed themselves more frequently in high-risk
situations, carried weapons to school more often, and were more likely
to be victims of violence. Violence was found to be relatively common in
the rural schools on the periphery of a large metropolitan area. In addition,
violent behavior was accompanied by maladaptive belief systems and associated
with drug use. |
Windle, M. (1994).
Substance use, risky behaviors, and victimization among a U.S. national
adolescent sample. Addiction, 89, 175-182.
|
Using data from the National Adolescent Student Health Survey, the
interrelations among substance use, risky (dangerous) behaviors, and victimization
were studied among a sample of 8th and 10th grade students. Similar to
earlier research, victimization was found to be associated with higher
levels of substance use. The variable of risky behaviors was the most powerful
predictor of level of victimization and also to be significantly correlated
with substance use. For girls, higher levels of drug use and risky behaviors
were associated with a higher level of victimization than was found for
boys. This was found to be particularly true regarding attempts at forced
sexual relations and having things taken by force. Implications for long-term
and short-term health consequences with regard to risky behaviors and violent
victimization are discussed. |
Weapon-carrying and Adolescent Violence:
DuRant, R. H., Getts,
A. G., Cadenhead, C., & Woods, E. R. (1995). The association between
weapon-carrying and the use of violence among adolescents living in or
around public housing. Journal of Adolescence, 18, 579-592.
|
Using a cross-sectional anonymous survey design, the author examined
the respo nses of 225 Black adolescents, 11-19 years of age and living
in or around nine HUD housing projects in Georgia. The two main dependent
variables were the number of days within the 30 previous days that a weapon
had been carried and the frequency that a hidden weapon had been carried
within the previous year. A weapon was defined for the purpose of this
study as a gun, knife, or club. Weapon carrying was measured using items
from the Denver Youth Self-Reported Delinquency Questionnaire and the CDC's
Youth Risk Behavior Survey. Data indicates that the number of days a weapon
was carried during the previous 30 days was significantly correlated with
previous exposure to violence and victimization scale, degree of family
conflict, and severity of corporal punishment and discipline. It is argued
that the data supports the cultural transmission theory. The theory proposes
that the use of violence by adolescents' is learned within intimate primary
group settings. It is further suggested that experiencing or being a victim
of violence likely increases the degree to which an adolescent is prepared
to use violence against others by carrying a weapon. The authors argue
that their data suggest that weapon carrying by adolescents, while not
itself a violent behavior, is associated with the same set of risk factors
that are linked with the use of interpersonal violence. As such, weapon-carrying
should be considered to be a part of the behavioral risk profile of aggression
and violence. |
Preventing Youth-related Violence:
Brendtro, L. K.,
& Long, N. J. (1994). Violence begets violence: Breaking conflict cycles.
Journal of Emotional and Behavioral Problems, 3 (1), 2-7.
|
This article discusses the way in which the public responds to reports
of increased violence of adolescents yet ignore the social underpinnings
that exacerbates and drives youthful delinquency. Discussions center on
the current punitive punishment response to adolescents who commit violent
crimes, e.g., get tough and kill kids, and on understanding the conflict
cycle wherein a youth is "caught up in a sequence of escalating events,"
and society literally fights violence with violence. The conflict cycle
is demonstrated as having four inner-related circuitous properties: stress,
feelings, behavior, and reaction. For an individual caught up in a sequence
of escalating events the cycle can be described as: stress evoking irrational
beliefs which trigger feelings of distress which drive defensive behavior
and this behavior provokes reciprocal reactions (punishment) from society
(or adult). The authors argue the war on violence must be fought like a
three-front war utilizing primary prevention, early intervention, and the
restoration of social bonds. |
Coie, J. D. (1996). Prevention
of violence and antisocial behavior. In R. Peters & R. J. McMahon (Eds.),
Preventing childhood disorders, substance abuse, and delinquency. Thousand
Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
|
The author argues that before prevention trials for youth at-risk for
violence or antisocial behavior can be developed research-based answers
to some basic questions must be formulated. These questions include: who
is the target of the intervention, the timing interval of the intervention,
and the motivation of the at risk population. A developmental model of
risk for adolescent antisocial behavior is offered. Implications of the
developmental model for prevention include the ability for early identification
of children most likely to engage in antisocial activity in adolescence,
the advantages of implementing programs for early prevention of aggression
an antisocial behavior, and the idea that risk is not a static characteristic
of the child but rather a developmental process. |
Corvo, K. (1997). Community-based
youth violence prevention: A framework for planners and founders. Youth
& Society, 28 (3), 291-316.
|
A conceptual framework is developed to guide those seeking to establish
or enhance community-based youth violence prevention programs. Current
approaches to prevention and intervention are reviewed along with the various
explanatory models linked to these approaches. Among those discussed are:
the Public Health Model, school-based conflict resolution/mediation, social
skills training, family interventions, peer/gang interventions, rites of
passage programs, mentoring, and community-based rehabilitation programs.
Several suggestions are made for developing successful programs. These
include specification of the problem to the service area, problem definitions
based on theoretical or causal models compatible to the proposed program,
youth violence considered a distinct phenomena that varies in severity,
etiology, and conditions of enactment, youth violence understood with respect
to its dynamics and psychosocial complexity can highlight opportunities,
and the importance of locating, defining, and prioritizing risk factors
provides precision and pragmatic guidance in program development. |
Creighton, A., & Kivel,
P. (1992). Helping teens stop violence: A practical guide for counselors,
educators, and parents. Emeryville, CA: Publishers Group West.
|
This hands-on, practical guide to family and relationship violence
prevention is presented by Allan Creighton, director of the Teen Program
Battered Women's Alternatives, a comprehensive education and support service
for youth dealing with abuse, and Paul Kivel, co-founder of the Oakland
Men's Project, a multiracial community-based violence prevention program
dedicated through education with youths, adults and communities to eliminating
male violence and promoting cross-gender and cross-racial alliance. The
material in this book focuses on how adults can be more powerful allies
for young people. Specific sections deal with preparing teens for work,
liberation theory and practice (i.e., power imbalance), and a family and
dating violence program. Included within the topic areas are curriculums
and classroom and workshop strategies, as well as techniques for conducting
long-term support groups for those youth dealing with abuse. |
Guerra, N. G., Tolan, P. H., &
Hammond, W. R. (1994). Prevention and treatment of adolescent violence.
In L. D. Eron, J.H. Gentry, & P. Schlegel (Eds.), Reason to hope: A
psychosocial perspective on violence and youth. Washington, DC: American
Psychological Association.
|
These authors focus on preventive and treatment interventions for aggression
and violence among adolescents using a public health model of primary,
secondary, and tertiary (treatment) programs. They conclude that at the
individual level, programs focusing on social-cognitive skills appear to
have the greatest impact on adolescence at the primary and secondary level,
while at the systems level, programs directed at impacting environmental
influences related to the learning of aggression appear to have the greatest
impact. Among their recommendations are the need for development of evaluation
methods that adequately reflect the diversity of approaches and the specific
issues in applying prevention. It is suggested that in order to make any
real difference, it is important to strive for an integration of individual,
family, social group, and community interventions. |
Hampton, R. L., Jenkins, P., &
Gullotta, T. P. (1996). Preventing violence in America. Thousand Oaks,
CA: Sage Publications.
|
This volume consists of a collection thirteen chapters by various authors
who address violence and violence prevention in the United States. Among
the topics addressed are the social context of violent behavior in families,
the link between community and family violence, violence in communities
of color, the value of including a "higher power" in preventing violence,
and media influence. Some chapters are devoted specifically to issues of
prevention. However, prevention and program development is a consistent
theme throughout all the chapter presentations. |
Haugen, H. L. (1997). Prevention
of youth violence: A resource guide for youth development and family life
professionals and volunteers. Ithaca, NY: Cornell Cooperative Extension.
|
The material in this publication is a revision of original research
published by the Army Family Advocacy Program Prevention Resource Manual
produced by the staff of the Cornell University Family Life Development
Center. The revision is designed to allow access of the material by a wider
audience of youth violence prevention professionals and volunteers. Among
the topics discussed: risk and resiliency, violence prevention strategies,
tips on selecting a successful program, and profiles on selected prevention
programs. In addition there is a listing of youth violence prevention organizations
complete with contact information. |
Hess, D. (1997). Violence prevention
and service learning. Social Educator, 61 (5), 279-281.
|
Service learning programs are being increasingly investigated as one
aspect of comprehensive school-based violence prevention programs. Projects
should contain four essential characteristics: meaningful activities, skills-based
instruction, recognition of student effort, and clear expectations for
non-violent behavior. It is cautioned that service learning programs are
not a cure-all as no single program can adequately address any complex
social problem. However, the author persuasively argues that social studies
based service learning programs have the potential to reduce violence in
schools when they provide students with meaningful activities, explicitly
teach necessary skills, recognize effort, and have clear anti-violence
norms. |
Johnson, D. W., & Johnson,
R. T. (1995). Why violence prevention programs don't work--and what does.
Educational Leadership, 52 (5), 63-68.
|
It is argued that many violence prevention programs don't work because
their aim is primarily to provide political cover for school officials
and politicians rather than focus on the long-term needs of the students.
What students need is to constructively learn how to manage conflict without
physical or verbal violence. Reasons cited for the poor performance of
many violence prevention programs are poor targeting, the providing of
materials but failure to implement the program, confusing what works in
neighborhoods with what works in schools, and an unrealistic understanding
of the social forces that push youths towards violence. Several principles
are suggested that may help schools accomplish their goals. These include:
going beyond prevention to conflict resolution, realistic elimination of
conflicts, creation of a cooperative context, decreasing in-school risk
factors, the use of controversy to show that conflicts can be positive,
and teaching all students how to constructively resolve conflicts. |
Pereira, C., & Rodriguez, K.
(1997). Linking violence prevention and good social studies: Research and
development. Social Education, 61 (5), 282-289.
|
Over a period of three years the Youth for Justice coalition designed
and implemented school-based programs to test the hypothesis: would increasing
the affinity for social institutions, such as law, government, and community,
in combination with increased cognitive and social skills in those areas,
result in changes in students beliefs and actions? Research sites were
designed in Los Angeles and Chicago. Assessments were made regarding the
extent to which the program increased knowledge in community awareness,
including the meaning of community, its needs and problems, and the students
role in influencing change; increases in cognitive skills relating to conflict
perceptions and resolutions; attitudes related to resiliency; and influences
on behavior with respect to participation in or reaction to violence. Three
strategy components were incorporated: law-related, conflict resolution,
and service learning with each strategy component including knowledge,
skills, beliefs, and action components. Each of the strategy components
put students in contact with outside resource persons and stress collaboration
over competition or individual work. Although results are preliminary,
the first year findings indicate that compared to a control group, program
participants showed a significant decrease in normative beliefs about the
acceptability of aggression. |
Powell, K. E, & Hawkins, D.
F. (1996). Youth violence prevention: Descriptions and baseline data from
13 evaluation projects. A supplement to American Journal of Preventive
Medicine, 12 (5), 1-134.
|
This compilation details the results of 13 evaluation studies aimed
at preventing and reducing adolescent violence. Among the programs evaluated
are Richmond Youth Against Violence, The Students for Peace Project, Supporting
Adolescents with Guidance and Employment, The Safe Dates Project, and PeaceBuilders.
The prevention and intervention programs detailed consist of both school-based
and community-based programs. These reports consider and supplement previous
deficiencies in the evaluation literature. The deficiencies in the evaluation
literature include: not heeding known epidemiologic patterns of violence,
failing to differentiate types of violence, and failing to differentiate
the levels of risk-influence addressed by intervention. These reports demonstrate
that programs can and should be evaluated and that characteristics such
as random assignment are plausible. In addition, they identify the importance
of the setting in program implementation, program use, and program impact. |
Schaffner, L., Shick, S., &
Stein, N. (1997). Changing policy in San Francisco: Girls in the juvenile
justice system. Social Justice, 24 (4), 187(25).
|
A community task force project was developed in response to concern
with the circumstances of young girls in the San Francisco juvenile justice
system; a system ignoring the fact that more and more girls were entering
into the juvenile justice system. Among the challenges faced was that of
looking at girls situated in a structural system that was built and dominated
by males. Local political pressure was geared at reducing the rate of juvenile
incarceration necessitating the need for preventive programs and alternatives
to incarceration. Among the subjects reviewed by the author prior to making
policy recommendations were the nature of the female offenses, a developmental
perspective vs. adolescent delinquency, the medical, psychological, and
emotional needs of young female offenders, and a review of placement alternatives.
The authors argue that community task force efforts are effective agents
of social change. |
Youth violence prevention:
Research findings and peer led programs.Tucson, AZ: College of Agriculture,
The University of Arizona
|
The findings and programs presented in this work are the result of
the combined efforts of the I nstitute of Children, Youth, and Families,
School of Family and Consumer Resources, and the Arizona Cooperative Extension,
4-H Youth Development. The booklet is divided into two sections: current
literature and peer led strategies. The current literature section covers
the key theories of violence, trends in youth violence, and youth violence
prevention and intervention information. The second section focuses on
peer assisted learning and peer led youth violence prevention programs.
An appendix provides researchers information from 25 peer led programs
located in Michigan, southern Arizona, California, and the United Kingdom.
These geographically diverse areas provided a wide variation in demographic
and program formats. The program summaries are presented in a common format
designed to assist the reader in locating pertinent information. According
to the authors the summaries presented are "a compilation of real word,
present day programs utilizing a peer assisted learning model." References
and selected bibliographies are also included. |
Tolan, P., & Guerra, N. (1994).
What Works in Reducing Adolescent Violence: An Empirical Review of the
Field. Center for the Study and Prevention of Violence.
|
Through an examination of available empirical evidence on the effects
of existing programs directed toward reducing adolescent violence, the
authors identify anti-violence programs that seem to work, that do not
seem to work, and that have not been adequately evaluated. For this purpose
violent behavior, e.g., serious and extreme behavior that is intended to
cause physical harm to another person, is distinguished from aggressive
behavior, which is often less extreme and not limited to physical harm.
From epidemiological data four basic characteristics of violence emerge:
violence is prevalent throughout our society, most violence occurs among
acquaintances, adolescence is a time of heightened violence, and violence
risk differs among adolescents. In addition, four types of adolescent violence
are addressed: situational, relationship, predatory, and psychopathological.
Interventions and their effectiveness/ineffectiveness are discussed in
terms of individual-level interventions, e.g., psychological processes,
social casework intervention, and biomedical methods, close interpersonal
relation interventions, proximal social contexts interventions, and societal
macrosystems. |
Trone, J., Armstrong, M., &
Sullivan, M. (1998). Beyond blame and panic: Institutional strategies for
preventing and controlling adolescent violence. New York: Vera Institute
of Justice.
|
This piece outlines strategies for reducing adolescent violence. Summarized
are recent research findings and indicate solutions to the problem by describing
practical innovations in courts, child welfare agencies, schools, and community-based
organizations. A prominent theme running through the article concerns connecting
adolescents to honest, unambiguous adults from these institutions. A brief
overview of the problem of adolescent violence is followed by a look at
courts, communities, and schools. An electronic version of this publication
is available at http://www.vera.org. |
Wolfe, D. A., Wekerle, C., & Scott, K. (1997). Alternatives to violence:
Empowering youth to develop healthy relationships. Thousand Oaks, CA.:
Sage Publications.
|
This book argues that youth, by virtue of their developmental level,
motivation, current interests, and future needs are well suited for the
investment of time and energy by researchers in developing programs intended
to reduce intimate and interpersonal violence. In advocating and promoting
healthy, nonviolent relationships, five main themes are developed: 1) the
expression of violence is most commonly seen in the context of relationships;
2) current policies to address personal violence are outdated and superficial;
3) violence does not affect everyone equally--it is engrained in cultural
expressions of power and inequality, and affects women, children, and minorities
most significantly; 4) prevention of violence entails building on the positive
(through empowerment) in the context of relationships, not just focusing
on individual weaknesses or deviance; and 5) youth are important resources
and part of the solution. This book is a companion piece to The Youth Relationship
Manual: A Group Approach to the Prevention of Woman Abuse and the Promotion
of Healthy Relationships. |
Wolfe, D. A., Wekerle, C., Reitzel-Jaffe,
D., Grasley, C., Pittman, A., Lefebvre, L., & Stumpf, J. (1996). The
youth relationship manual: A group approach for the prevention of woman
abuse and the promotion of healthy relationships. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
Publications.
|
This manual is prepared for the express purpose of assisting adults
in empowering adolescents ages 14-16 to end violence in relationships through
education, skill development, and social competence. This program, The
Youth Relationships Project, reflects an incremental change approach whereby
adolescents first begin by learning about the issues and about themselves.
The program then expands to effect changes within their peer groups, the
teen culture, and the broader community. Through a youth-centered educational
program young male adolescents are assisted in identifying and expressing
feelings assertively, to recognize and respect personal rights of their
female partners, and to own responsibility for their behaviors. Young adolescent
females are taught to understand their personal rights, how to take care
of their own safety, and how to express themselves assertively. Although
originally designed as an after-school program it can be used as part of
the educational curriculum. The manual contains detailed information on
selecting facilitators, 18 sessions complete with a list of activities,
and time frame guidelines for each of the activity segments provided. Sessions
include issues surrounding power in relationships, relationship abuse,
date rape, choosing partners, confronting sexism, media and sexism, and
several sessions concerning getting to know the community and getting out
and about in the community. |
Victimization:
Within the general population, children and adolescents are at significant
risk for victimization and prevailing cultural attitudes greatly enhance
this risk. However, within the population of children and adolescents,
there are populations that have even higher risk for victimization. For
these groups vulnerability to victimization is based on a differing sexual
orientation, gender, or physical disabilities. Victimization may occur
through sexual, physical, emotional, or verbal abuse and can have long-lasting
negative psychological consequences.
Davis, R. C., Lurigio,
A. J., & Skogan, W. G. (1997). Victims of crime, 2nd edition. Thousand
Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
|
This volume is a collection of work by various researchers in the area
of crime victimization, identifies recent advances and research, policies,
and programs in crime victimization. Part one focuses on victimization
and its effects. Topics discussed include patterns of criminal victimization,
sexual assault, the developmental victimology of children, hate crimes,
and the psychological consequences of crime. The second part of the volume
focuses on providing assistance to victims including violence prevention
through victim assistance an d victim rights and services. Part three looks
at the criminal justice response to the victim. Extensive references and
a detailed index are provided. |
Eron, L. D., Gentry, J. H.,
& Schlegel, P. (1994). Reason to hope: A psychosocial perspective on
violence and youth. Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association.
|
Part three of this book contains chapters dealing with populations
vulnerable to victimization. Susan Sorenson and Patricia Bowie discuss
specifically the vulnerabilities of girls and young women. Following a
brief overview of factors contributing to female victimization, the authors
briefly discuss and cite relevant literature regarding specific categories
of female victimization, specifically, homicide, child physical abuse and
sexual assault, and dating violence. Anthony D'Augelli and Lawrence Dark
discuss the victimization of lesbian, gay, and bisexual youth, focusing
upon patterns of victimization in family and peer domains. In conclusion
they discuss public policy recommendations and intervention strategies.
Judith Levey and Vasilios Lagos review recent research and literature related
to youth with disabilities emphasizing research pertaining to physical
abuse, sexual abuse, or both. Included are treatment and prevention program
recommendations, public policy recommendations, and future research needs. |
Jensen, G.F., & Brownfield, D. (1986).
Gender, lifestyles, and victimization: Beyond routine activity. Violence
and Victims, 1 (2), 85-99.
|
Beginning with a theoretical review and critique of lifestyle theory
and opportunity theory, the authors tested whether gender, routine activities,
and delinquent activities were correlates to adolescent victimization.
Results taken from the data indicate that activities that involve the pursuit
of fun are more victimogenic than activities that passively put individuals
at risk, victimization and delinquent activity are positively related,
when controlling for delinquent activity, gender differences in victimization
are reduced. |
Kuther, T. L., & Fisher,
C. B. (1998). Victimization by community violence in young adolescents
from a suburban city. Journal of Early Adolescence, 18 (1), 53-76.
|
A sample of 123 6th-8th grade students were tested using an exploratory
model of victimization-distress relation. Participants were predominately
from middle-to upper-middle-class families. Self-reports were measured
using Youth's Victimization by Community Violence Questionnaire, Assertiveness
Scale for Adolescents, Ways of Coping Questionnaire, Perceived Social Support
Scale from Family, Revised Children's Manifest Anxiety Scale, and the Hopelessness
Scale for Children. Focus groups were assembled after data collection in
order to explore participant definitions of violence. Results indicated
that over one-half of the students reported being victimized by community
violence. Violent incidents were defined by the groups as those incidents
in which student safety was endangered, whether by threatened or actual
confrontations. This included being chased, hit, mugged, and wounded. |
Lauritsen, J. L., Laub, J. H.,
& Sampson, R. J. (1992). Conventional and delinquent activities: Implications
for the prevention of violent victimization among adolescents. Violence
and Victims, 7(2), 91-108.
|
Data from the National Youth Survey (NYS) and the Monitoring the
Future Study: A Continuing Study of the Lifestyles and Values of Youth
(MTF) were used to investigate the relationship between activity involvement
and the risk of assault and robbery victimization among adolescents
in the United States. The findings suggest that certain adolescent
activities have a higher correlation to the risk of violence, such
that those adolescents who engage in delinquent activities are at
the highest risk of assault and robbery victimization. Among the implications
presented the authors suggest that only certain adolescent activities
appear to be related to victimization risk, conventional activities
have little effect on risk once socio-economic characteristics and
delinquency are accounted for, and a key component in the prevention
of adolescent violence is delinquency prevention. |
|