Reviews: Some Old Observations Revisited |
-- a university of arizona
course on methods and approaches for studying the future
|
The Age of Discontinuity:
Guidelines to Our Changing Society, Peter Drucker, Harper & Row, 1969/1978,
402 pages. The original book was published
in 1969, and an updated preface was added in the 1978 edition, noting the earlier
comments were basically still relevant. The main theme is that the continuity
of the old trends or issues for social and cultural changes were ending. The
book does not "forecast", but looks at the major changes occurring
in the foundations that will affect changes. He identifies 4 discontinuities.
He further states that the
dynamics of population changes are different in three major sections of the
world (developed countries of industrialized world, developed countries of the
Soviet Bloc, and the developing countries of the third world. The "age
of discontinuity" is not a pessimistic situation, it provides ample opportunities
for new actions, so it really is an "age of opportunity". How to Lie With Statistics.
1954. Darel Huff. W.W. Norton. 142p. This book has had many printings
and the information is still applicable. It is written in a popularized style
and uses examples to clarify the points. Included are problems with samples
with build in biases, use of the term "average", making a big deal
of data that does not warrant it, and misuse of graphs and figures. Limits to Growth.
1971. Donella H. Meadows, et al. Universe Books. 205p. A computer model of the
world from 1900 to 2100 using five variables: resources, food per capita, industrial
output per capita, pollution, and population. A variety of "computer runs"
allow examples ranging from disaster to smooth transition to a sustainable world.
Discussion is centered around each of the variables as a "limit" to
continued growth. The book is one of the earliest large scale models, and coming
at the beginning of the modern environmental movement caused a great deal of
positive and negative comments. This book was sponsored by the (then new) Club
of Rome and is one of a series of the "Project on the Predicament of Mankind".
It was primarily by a group of systems-thinking people, mostly at MIT, USA.
(See updated book titled "Beyond the Limits"). Models of Doom: A Critique
of the Limits to Growth. 1973. H.S.D. Cole et al. Universe Books. 244. A detailed critique of the
"Limits to Growth" addressing assumptions, methodologies, and results.
The authors believe the "Limits to Growth" approach is negative in
outlook and simply "computerizes" inappropriate theories. Primarily
by economists at the University of Sussex, UK. A brief response by the authors
of the "Limits to Growth" is included, focusing on five major areas
of disagreement: short term vs long term models, using results of a single model
vs large scale considerations, stability vs dynamic characteristics of specific
variables, use of "perfect" models vs "imperfect" models
for policy making, and role of mankind relative to the earth. The Unprepared Society:
Planning for a Precarious Future. Donald Michael. Harper Colophon. New York,
1968. 132. This is an early book by
a well know social psychologist about futures, long range planning, resistance
to organizational change, and new ways at looking at society. He concludes that
the convergence of social and technological trends will lead to more extensive
use of long range planning and that we are unprepared to do that (over the next
20 or so years). This is an early "futures" oriented book. Avoiding 1984: Moving
Toward Independence. Robert Theobald. Swallow Press, Ohio State University,
1982, 114p. The 1984 here is in reference
to the George Orwell book "1984", published in 1948 (the last two
digits were transposed to come up with 1984). That book identified a world of
scarcity, cruelty, and constant warfare. Theobald believes we can avoid that
picture of the future, but we must be proactive to do it and make significant
changes. He identifies four scenarios for 2000 (status quo, high technology/high
growth, low technology/low growth, and management transformational), discusses
driving forces and social issues, and ends with how one ought to be acting in
today's world (creating a desirable educational system, managing complex systems,
problem/possibility focusers, and becoming involved. Theobald has been involved
in Arizona futures (he lived here at one time) and believes in the need for
major transformation of society. The Change Resisters:
How they prevent progress and what managers can do about them. 1981. George
Odiorne. 275 p. Sections address: how to
recognize and deal with an anti-planning attitude, how to avoid activity traps
(you think you are working but you are not producing), destroying plans by false
analogies, how to kill ideas by false obstacles and arguments, distorting facts
and false generalizations, using crises to avoid change, dealing the bureaucracy,
how to band together to resist change, and managing change in the world of change
resisters. The last section, how to manage change, includes: living strategically,
getting a broad picture of the world, evaluating assumptions, and manage by
anticipation rather than reaction.
Go to the "review of all books" large listing